The transitions taken from Jane Austen’s and Charles Dickens’ novels show differences in matrimony proposals. The type of rhetoric used by each adult male causes different effects.
In the first extract taken from Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice. the adult male grounds that he must put an illustration for all others in his parish by taking a married woman. Not merely will he hold made usage of the advice given him by his patronne. Lady Catherine de Bourgh. but this married woman shall give him happiness. “First. that I think it a right thing for every reverend in easy fortunes ( like myself ) to put the illustration of marriage in his parish. Second. that I am convinced it will add really greatly to my felicity ; and thirdly… that it is the peculiar advice and recommendation of the really baronial lady whom I have the award of naming patronne. ” ( lines 1-8 ) He believes that this act of marriage will non merely be good for him but besides for the one being proposed to. She will bask his superb manners. the advantages of his high power. every bit good as the kindness shown by Lady Catherine.
This proposal seems to be said in a businesslike tone. by one who is certain of success. He trusts that she will see the benefits of such a matrimony between them and for those grounds she will accept his generous offer. Her reaction nevertheless may non be taken the manner he would wish. Because this is said in such a businesslike tone and non fondly. she may deny his proposal.
The adult male in Charles Dickens’ book wants to get married the proposed for one ground: love. “You know what I am traveling to state. I love you… what I mean is that I am under the influence of some enormous attraction…” ( lines 1-4 ) He can non command his desires ; he has tried and failed. He must get married. and he shall make whatsoever she may wish to carry through the effort. “You could pull me to fire. you could pull me to H2O. you could pull me to the gallows. you could pull me to any decease. you could pull me to anything I have most avoided. you could pull me to any exposure and shame. ” ( lines 5-9 ) Her credence is good for her wellbeing as good. Anything her bosom desires. she shall have. His high repute would protect hers. She may even take pride in her hubby for the work he puts in. When he asks this
adult female to get married him. it is said non to take advantage of her. but to ease his bosom and enable him to love her in peace.
The proposal this adult male makes is dear. He hopes to derive her manus in matrimony but is non certain she will give it. He wishes to give everything over to her to hold her as a married woman. The adult female will see love and a good agreement for her life. She will most likely accept his offer because it is full of love every bit good as it holds net income for her.
The effectivity of each proposal shown in these two transitions is non shown yet one can deduce the hereafter of each. The type of oratory given in each extract determines the reaction of the adult females. Therefore. the statements. premises. attitudes. and the enunciation used will act upon the decision.